|
||
The best flip market in America isn't sexy
ATTOM's Q1 2026 flip report buried the most interesting number in its footnotes. In Pittsburgh, the typical flip returned 85.9% — the fattest margin of any metro over a million people. Buffalo cleared 84%, with Virginia Beach at 74.9%. Meanwhile every STR guru’s first pick markets returned almost nothing: Austin 2%, Dallas 4.3%, San Antonio 5.1%. The Sunbelt boomtowns are where flips go to die.
The reason is basis. A Pittsburgh single-family in a workable neighborhood still trades near $135K: below the $217K metro median, right in the $100K–$200K purchase tier ATTOM says returned 32% nationally. Meanwhile the sub-$50K "steals" investors chase lost 14%. That low basis is what keeps both exits alive, it funds the fat resale spread, and it's the only reason a host-spec renovation can beat the long-term lease after operations.
Barely, though. Model Pittsburgh's ~$145 ADR at ~59% occupancy and the unit grosses about $2,600 a month. Strip 30% for operations and the net just clears the $1,650 lease by roughly $170. That isn't a hold — it's a coin flip against a certain 85.9% resale margin. The boomtowns teach the rule in reverse: overpay going in and neither exit works.
What we'd do: In a value metro, take the flip-to-sell margin unless the modeled STR net beats the lease by $400+/month after operations. Here it clears ~$170, so we'd renovate to a spec that satisfies both a resale buyer and a host, list at ARV, and pivot to hosting only if it doesn't sell.
|
The spread flatters the hold. Strip the 30% operations drag from the $2,600 STR gross instead of the spread and STR net lands near $1,820, about $170 over the $1,650 lease. Set that thin, uncertain edge against a resale flip clearing the highest big-metro margin nationally, and the sale wins. The low basis keeps both exits open; the operations math picks one.
Figures modeled from AirDNA and Rabbu Pittsburgh comps plus ATTOM Q1 2026 — not a specific active listing.
|
||
|
Rabbu does one thing the flip-to-host underwriter needs early: enter an address or browse its marketplace of for-sale homes and it returns projected annual STR revenue, ADR, and occupancy pulled from nearby active listings.
For the Pittsburgh question: does the hold beat the sale? It's the fastest way to sanity-check the nightly rate before an offer, without opening a spreadsheet. It also generates a lender-ready projection doc, handy when the exit is a DSCR refinance rather than a sale. The catch: Rabbu leans on market averages, so it undervalues a genuinely well-run listing and can't see the operations cost that decides a thin spread. Treat it as a first-pass filter, not the final underwrite.
|
01 — As of July 1, Austin requires Airbnb, VRBO, and Booking.com to display each rental's city license number on the listing — and to pull unlicensed listings within 10 days of a city request. Enforcement moved from the operator to the platform. Unpermitted rentals just lost the middleman. Source→
02 — Ford River Township, Michigan voted in June to ban short-term rentals in every zone except commercial. Existing permitted operators are grandfathered; everyone else is shut out. In small townships, one board meeting can erase the STR exit entirely. Source→
03 — Placentia, California reopened its short-term rental applications on June 6, ending a moratorium in place since September 2025. While big metros tighten, some suburbs are quietly reopening — a reminder that the permit map moves in both directions, not just toward the exits. Source→
Worth Watching — STR headline ADR is up ~1.5% for 2026 — but AirDNA notes the gain is partly a mirage: higher-priced resort supply entering the market lifts the average while occupancy eases ~1%. Investors underwriting off market-average ADR are overstating their own property's rate. Source→
Which unsexy metro is on your radar? Reply and let us know.
|
The flip side of short-term rentals BUY IT · FLIP IT · HOST IT |